Arizona and minorities

Here’s part of an open letter to Arizona state officials about their immigration policies and other actions towards minorities in that state.

“Some people say that as Arizona’s top leaders, you are actively engaged in an unprecedented ethnic cleansing campaign against the red-brown peoples of this state.

No doubt you not only disagree, but you take umbrage because you perhaps consider yourself part of a movement that is concerned primarily with national security, with sealing the porous U.S./Mexico border, with mounting campaigns against illegal immigration, and lastly, with promoting the virtues of U.S. culture, a culture that you fear is being eroded daily by invading and uncontrolled hordes from south of the border.”

. . . . And yet, I’m sure you are aware that on Dec 31, one of you, outgoing state schools superintendant of schools, Tom Horne, is set to declare Tucson’s K-12 Mexican American Studies program to be out of compliance with HB 2281, Arizona’s anti-ethnic studies law that goes into effect the very next day.

Despite this, you cannot see how this can be interpreted as being part of an ethnic cleansing campaign? planation. . . .

Part of the problem in debating these issues is that we utilize different vocabularies and we also live different realities. Yet the problem is actually beyond language. You need to walk in our shoes or you need to have the experience of being singled out because of our red-brown skin to be able to understand why we view the world differently and why we interpret your movement to be inimical to our very existence.

Let me offer alternative terminology for what you are doing. I would argue that what you are engaged in is not so much ethnic cleansing, but a continuation of the colonial policies of reducciones – a project carried out by the Spanish empire in the Americas during the 1500s-1800s. This included the region that is today called the U.S. Southwest.

Never heard of it? They were akin to this nation’s Indian Removal policies of the 19th century. Tied to them were the Indian Boarding Schools. Indian Removal either constituted outright genocide or forced migrations. This resulted in land loss and the de-rooting of peoples that had been living in what is today the United States for many thousands of years. The philosophical foundation for the boarding schools was: “kill the Indian, save the man.” . . .

So when you enact laws that require us to prove our citizenship, when you enact laws that forbid us from learning our thousands-of-year cultures from this very continent, then you give us but one clear message: the need to once again prove our humanity. You also send out another message: not welcome. But you seem not content with sending that message either. Next is the Arizona nullification of birthright citizenship and the 14th amendment. And subsequently, you now want children to also turn in their own parents.

Read the entire piece at Column of the Americas.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

0 Responses to Arizona and minorities

  1. Aaron Adams says:

    It always makes me sad to hear about our current immigration policies. Other than the Native Americans, all other people living in this country are descendants of immigrants. I do understand the concern over so many illegal immigrants moving across the U.S. boarders, but I am not sure that I can really agree with all of these laws that are being passed to keep Mexicans out.

  2. ehliyet says:

    I follow you constantly. This kind of hope that you continue to the shares. good luck.

  3. RodneyMcDowell says:

    Thats all good but why would someone want to come to another country with spite and hate, a dislike of the national flag and its peoples and an obvious dislike of the country, rules and laws that govern it…..to study the culture of its own nation.

    I think a lot of dumb asses arte under the impression they can just come waltzing across out borders and change out country, our rules, our laws, our peoipkle, our way of life, our religions, our holidays, blow up our buildings and landmarks and commit mass murder of our peoples….

    Youre lucky you get sent back home instead of shot on sight…..ever consider those facts dumb ass ?

  4. I have to say that for the last couple of hours i have been hooked by the amazing articles on this website. Keep up the wonderful work.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s